Miami will play the biggest game of its unbeaten season without the player its offense runs through. Malachi Toney, the sophomore receiver with 73 catches, 1,027 yards and 13 touchdowns, suffered a high ankle sprain in Wednesday's practice and will have surgery, ESPN's Pete Thamel reported Wednesday night, which rules him out of Saturday's game at Notre Dame and beyond. The Hurricanes, 8-0 and No. 1 in the first College Football Playoff rankings, kick off against the No. 11 Fighting Irish at 7:30 p.m. ET on NBC from Notre Dame Stadium.
The news turned quickly. Earlier Wednesday, ESPN reported that Toney was uncertain for the game but expected to try to play, and that the injury was not expected to be a long-term setback. By that night the picture had changed. Recovery from a high ankle sprain typically takes at least four weeks, ESPN reported, and the first round of the playoff is six weeks away, so Miami could still get him back for the postseason. Miami's statement said only that he was hurt in practice and was undergoing further evaluation.
The loss is hard to overstate. Toney's 73 catches are the most among Power 4 receivers, and he has topped 100 all-purpose yards in six of Miami's eight games for an offense that leads the nation at 47.6 points a game. He and running back Mark Fletcher Jr. combined for five touchdowns last week in a 38-35 win over North Carolina, and a year ago his college debut, six catches for 82 yards and a touchdown, helped beat Notre Dame 27-24. Irish coach Marcus Freeman's assessment this week: "He's an eraser. He's as good as anyone you'll see." Miami still has quarterback Darian Mensah, who has thrown for 2,425 yards and 25 touchdowns with one interception. Cooper Barkate, a primary target for Mensah at Duke last season with 1,106 yards, is the logical first option for more work after 28 catches for 372 yards and four scores this year.
Notre Dame has injuries and urgency of its own. Linebacker Drayk Bowen, the team's leading tackler with 45, is out with an injured right ankle, the Associated Press reported, and defensive linemen Francis Brewu and Jason Onye were listed as questionable on Monday. Quarterback CJ Carr has 18 touchdown passes and one interception, and running back Nolan James Jr. has eight rushing scores after his second 100-yard game of the season in a 35-13 win over Navy. The Irish are 7-1, but their No. 11 playoff ranking, well below their No. 4 spot in the AP poll, leaves little room, and Miami is the last ranked team on their regular-season schedule. Freeman expects a physical night. "It will be a battle at the line of scrimmage," he said.
Traders moved on the news. Polymarket had Miami at about 34.5% to win on Wednesday morning and prices it at about 28.5% now, with Notre Dame at about 71.5%. The Irish were already favored before Toney got hurt, and DraftKings lists them by 7.5 points. The next word on Toney's surgery and timeline will shape the rest of Miami's season, which continues against Duke on Nov. 14. The next playoff rankings come out on Nov. 10.



