Trump has declared Biden's pardons VOID, VACANT, AND OF NO FURTHER FORCE OR EFFECT, on the grounds that they were signed by autopen. A declaration is one thing. A claim made by the Justice Department in a federal courtroom is another, and the second is the only thing a Kalshi market on the subject asks about. Whether the government will ever take that step matters because it would test how far a president's power over clemency reaches.
Kalshi traders put the chance that the department claims in federal court that any of Biden's pardons are void at 4% as of 1:59 p.m. ET on Nov. 20. The price was down 6 points in the last day, and it was unchanged over the week. This is a thin book: 0 contracts traded over the last day, though 10,162 contracts open. A price with so little trading behind it says more about the absence of conviction than about any settled view. Trading on the contract closes Jan. 1, 2027.
Why traders are skeptical
The legal backdrop explains much of the caution. Legal scholars say no mechanism exists to undo a pardon once granted. One law professor, quoted by Newsweek, says it has never been thought that a president has the ability to void a prior president's pardons. If that view prevails, any court claim would be arguing against the prevailing understanding of how pardons work.
The Oversight Committee has already gone further than speeches. It deemed Biden actions signed by autopen void in October 2025. A committee's finding, however, is not a claim put before a judge, and the market is asking about the latter. How much of that finding could be carried into litigation is not yet clear.
The argument may move to Congress
The politics are about to shift. Democrats take the House majority in January, and Rep. Robert Garcia is poised to chair the Oversight Committee. Garcia has called Biden's pardons a mistake, but he has also said that Blanket pardons can also be challenged, and state attorneys general are running their own investigations.
The reach of a pardon matters here. Presidential pardons cover only federal crimes, not state prosecutions, civil suits or impeachment. Challenges that come from state officials or from Congress would therefore not depend on a Justice Department filing at all.
Several things remain open. It is not yet clear whether the department will move from declaration to a court filing, which pardon any such filing would target, or whether a claim could reach a court before trading closes. Until one does, the question of whether a president can void another's pardon remains a matter of argument rather than a ruling, and traders are treating a court test as unlikely.



