Who gets clemency from a president decides who walks free, who keeps a conviction, and who is still owed money. A public tally of second-term clemency puts the cost to victims of waived restitution and fines at an estimated $1.3 billion. The question of how many people Trump will pardon in 2026 is therefore about more than a number. It is about how far the pardon power is being used, and through what channel.
Kalshi runs a year-end market that sorts the 2026 total into brackets. Traders put the lower-middle bracket at 51% as of 7:01 p.m. ET on Nov. 19, up 29 points in the last day and up 28 points over the week. That is a large swing, though it rests on a modest book: 461 contracts traded over the last day, with 4,315 contracts open. The bracket above it sits at 33%, with 58 contracts traded over the last day, so that price has little trading behind it. The very top bracket, covering the largest possible totals, is at 8%, and the bracket just beneath it is at 5%, down 16 points over the week. Those are the brackets traders have been abandoning. The market is not unanimous, and a substantial minority still expects hundreds of grants before the year ends. Trading in these contracts closes Jan. 1, 2027.
The larger the numbers in the news, the more it matters what is being counted. The same public tally shows cumulative clemency across the term of more than 1,700 individuals. A blanket pardon covering some 1,500 Capitol riot defendants accounts for a big share of that. A running total across the whole term cannot show how many grants have been issued in a single calendar year, and a high cumulative count does not mean the 2026 figure is already large. It is also not clear how a blanket pardon is tallied: as one act or as one grant per person, and whether the count is of individuals or of grants. Which basis applies could decide which bracket a year-end count falls into, and it is not yet clear whether the market follows the same convention.
The way clemency is being granted is the second part of the story. Reuters found that 96% of clemency grants fell short of Justice Department guidelines. According to the same tally, the vast majority of successful cases came through personal appeals to the White House rather than through the department's pardon office. That is a different system from one in which a pardon attorney reviews a petition and makes a recommendation. It also makes the pace hard to predict. A process driven by personal appeals can produce a burst of grants or a long lull with little warning.
What traders believe, then, is a bet on pace and on counting. The lurch toward the lower-middle bracket suggests they see a year total well short of what a large blanket action would produce, but they still give real weight to a count in the hundreds. An official tally of grants made in 2026 alone, and the precise rule for how the year's count is set, are the two things that would tell a reader most. Until those are clear, the market is best read as a split verdict on how often the president will use this power before the year ends, not as a count.



