The biggest question in the next Pennsylvania Senate race is not which challenger steps forward but what the incumbent does. Sen. John Fetterman has not yet said whether he will seek a second term or as a Democrat, according to the Inquirer. The paper also reports that he has left the door open to switching parties, including if Senate Democrats elect Chris Van Hollen as majority leader, a scenario in which he could leave the party. Whether he runs as a Democrat, under another label or not at all is the open question hanging over the seat.
His standing with his own party is part of the picture. Roughly three quarters of Pennsylvania Democratic voters held an unfavorable view of him in a September poll, the Inquirer reports. The challenger field is only beginning to form. According to the Inquirer, a candidate named Moor was first to announce for the seat. Rep. Brendan Boyle has decided to remain in the House as incoming chairman of the powerful Budget Committee. Rep. Conor Lamb, the paper reports, has said he did not plan to challenge Fetterman in a 2028 primary, though that could change.
Kalshi runs a separate contract for each name, asking whether that person will announce a run, so the prices do not add up to a single field. Every one of these contracts shows no trading over the last day, so each price is a loose reading of sentiment rather than a firm market verdict. Kalshi traders put Rep. Chris Deluzio at 87% as of 6:43 p.m. ET on Nov. 19, up 5 points over the week. That is the highest of the eight names, but it comes with 0 contracts traded over the last day and 1,481 contracts open. Kalshi has Malcolm Kenyatta and Summer Lee both at 46%. Lee's price was unchanged over the week, with 405 contracts open and 0 contracts traded over the last day. Kenyatta's price was up 5 points over the week on a very thin book, with only 11 contracts open and 0 contracts traded over the last day.
The incumbent himself is priced well below Deluzio. Fetterman is at 36% to announce a run, up 2 points over the week, on a thin book of 410 contracts open with 0 contracts traded over the last day. Madeleine Dean is at 32%, but only 36 contracts open sit behind that price, and 0 contracts traded over the last day. Boyle is at 5% with 1,550 contracts open, though 0 contracts traded over the last day.
The two biggest weekly swings sit on very small books. Lamb is at 27%, down 49 points over the week, with just 5 contracts open and 0 contracts traded over the last day. Chrissy Houlahan is at 17%, down 24 points over the week, with 37 contracts open and 0 contracts traded over the last day. What lies behind those moves is not clear, and with so little trading, neither price should be read as a firm judgment on whether either will run.
A price on a name is not an announcement, and several of these contracts are lightly traded at best. Together the prices offer a rough sense of how traders see the possible challengers, not a settled picture of the race. The clearest unsettled question is the incumbent's own decision on whether to run and under which party.



